Waiting Date:
Reading Date:	Clear Date
Finish Date:	Clear Date
Give Up Date:	Clear Date
Grade:	A+ A A- B+ B B- C+ C C- D+ D D- F+ F F-
	Comment before you read:
	Comment after you read: I have 2 issues with these books. Part of my problem with these books is that both Mogget and the Disreputable Dog are basically deus ex machina. God like characters that explain nothing, know everything and fix all problems and because of that all agency is taken away from the main characters. YA books should be about giving agency to teens and Garth Nix just refuses to do that.

Close without Saving

2 year ago stefanhayden finished reading Lirael: Daughter of the Clayr by Garth Nix. For 1 month stefanhayden read 720 pages at 21 pages a day.

I have 2 issues with these books. Part of my problem with these books is that both Mogget and the Disreputable Dog are basically deus ex machina. God like characters that explain nothing, know everything and fix all problems and because of that all agency is taken away from the main characters. YA books should be about giving agency to teens and Garth Nix just refuses to do that.